The Insider Who Never Said “Catch Me”: Can SEBI Prove Insider Trading When the Trader Is Not an Obvious Insider?
Insider-trading enforcement is relatively straightforward when the facts fit the conventional pattern: a person connected with the company obtains UPSI, trades shortly before the announcement and benefits when the information becomes public. However, the more difficult cases are those that fall outside this obvious pattern. Consider the following situation: (i) Sometime in January, Investor Z purchased the shares of Company A; (ii) In February, Company A initiates discussions w.r.t. acquisition with Company B; (iii) In March, the aforesaid transaction is put on hold; (iv) From April to June, there was again no discussion on (ii); (v) Then, suddenly, in July, there is a public announcement regarding the transaction. Assumptions here: 1. Investor Z has no formal connection with either Company A or Company B; 2. Investor Z makes a substantial gain out the transaction referred to above. As legal experts, the following issues arise for our consideration: (a) Can a mer...