When Debt Turns into Capital Investment: The EPC v. Matix Lesson on Preference Shares and Section 55
The Hon'ble Supreme Court’s ruling in EPC Constructions India Ltd. v. Matix Fertilizers and Chemicals Ltd. (2025) clarifies that preference shares—however structured—remains part of a company's share capital, and cannot be regarded as "debt". Even if classified as “financial liability” under Ind AS 32, legal character under the Companies Act still governs enforceability. A cautionary tale for investors and creditors relying on redeemable or “put option” structures to secure repayment. The Case in Brief In EPC Constructions (supra), the appellant had over ₹400 crores in receivables for project work. The appellant/ former operational creditor agreed to convert its dues into 8% Cumulative Redeemable Preference Shares (CRPS)—redeemable in three years. When the respondent/ debtor failed to redeem, the appellant (then in liquidation), through its liquidator, filed a Section 7 petition under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), claiming default on redemption. Both ...